While the world continues to focus primarily on the threat of Iran’s
nuclear weapons program, a potentially much greater nuclear threat has emerged
just to its east: Pakistan, the Islamic world’s only nuclear-weapons state
Pakistan is one of the world’s only eight declared nuclear powers and
probably the one that causes the most mischief. Pakistan sponsors and harbors
militant groups that carry out attacks in all of its neighbors: India,
Afghanistan, Iran, and even China.
Although Pakistan argues that its nuclear weapons are well-guarded, many
experts are not so sure, pointing out that the Taliban and other
militants have frequently struck at supposedly secure military bases with
impunity. More worrisome, though, is Pakistan’s history of proliferation, which
increases the chance that one day some element or the other in the Pakistani
military will provide nuclear materials to an even more dangerous third
party—or even to a stable country like Saudi Arabia, which could set off an
arms race in the Middle East.
Also troubling is the steady
radicalization of Pakistani’s military, which could at some point turn into the
ideological
equivalent of the Taliban. American lawmakers who constantly fret
about the irrationality of the Iranian government should take note of the
continuous Islamization of Pakistan’s military. Here are five things you need
to know about the world’s most dangerous nuclear weapons program.
Why does Pakistan have Nuclear Weapons?
At first glance, it may seem
strange that Pakistan has nuclear weapons, as it maintains close relations with
China and the United States, neither of which would allow it to be dismembered.
Even its rival India does not wish to see it collapse, but that doesn’t stop
Pakistan from having nuclear weapons largely for one reason—India.
This is not only because India
itself has nuclear weapons (ostensibly because China has them), but also to
achieve parity with a rival that is many times larger than it in terms of size,
population, and economic prowess.
Ultimately, however, nuclear
weapons give Pakistan reassurance that it will never be humiliated the way it
was in 1971, when Indian forces decisively defeated Pakistan in a two-front war
that lead to the independence of east Pakistan as Bangladesh. If Indian forces
were to ever enter Pakistani territory in such force again, it is likely that
Pakistan would compensate for its conventional military inferiority by using
battlefield nuclear weapons to prevent a repeat of its total defeat in 1971.
This plan makes India’s Cold
Start military doctrine—a swift incursion into Pakistan that would
capture vital territory before Pakistan could retaliate—hard to implement.
Nuclear weapons also help
Pakistan continue to bleed India. Pakistan’s possession of nuclear weapons are
considered its “shield” to guard against retaliation from any punitive strike
in response to attacks conducted by terrorists based in Pakistan. This gives
Pakistan significant leeway in making
mischief in India.
History
Pakistan conducted peaceful
nuclear research from the time of its independence but began a nuclear weapons
program in earnest only after its defeat by India in 1971. India itself
conducted a nuclear test in 1974 and
rejected proposals for a nuclear free zone in South Asia. Pakistan’s
nuclear weapons program began in 1972 under Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto,
who had always been a proponent of going nuclear. Bhutto famously declared:
“If India builds the bomb, we will eat grass or leaves, even go hungry, but we
will get one of our own.”
Indeed, it was Pakistan’s
poverty that held it back from pursuing a nuclear program in the 1960s, despite
reports that India was secretly working on nuclear weapons. To compensate for
this, and to accelerate the development of its own program, Pakistan resorted
to subterfuge, deceit, and help from generous friends in order to go nuclear.
Pakistan’s
nuclear weapons program took off under the leadership of Dr. Abdul Qadeer
(A.Q.) Khan, who began trying to enrich uranium at the secret Engineering
Research Laboratories (ERL) in 1976. Prior to this, A.Q. Khan worked from
1972-75 at the Physics Dynamic Research Laboratory in Amsterdam where he had
access to information on uranium enrichment. Subsequently, he left the
Netherlands for Pakistan
with secret documents that detailed the construction of a uranium
centrifuge. Once back in Pakistan, Khan’s laboratories developed a uranium
enrichment plant. Khan was convicted in absentia for theft in 1983; later on,
he was linked to the
sale of nuclear designs and materials to North Korea, Iran, Iraq,
and Libya.
In the meantime, a 1983 U.S.
State Department report
revealed that China had assisted Pakistan with its nuclear
program—most probably to keep India in check—and had even supplied Pakistan
with complete blueprints for a nuclear bomb. By 1984, Pakistan had the
ability to enrich uranium to weapons grade levels. Yet work stalled
for a few years in the late 1980s for a variety of reasons: American pressure
and Pakistani
fear of an Indian or Israeli strike. Throughout this period,
Pakistan continued to improve its deliver capabilities. Pakistan finally conducted
a nuclear test in 1998, in response to an Indian test that same year.
Current Capabilities
Pakistan currently possesses
about 120 nuclear weapons, more than India and Israel. Pakistan does not have a nuclear triad,
but that is likely to change soon with the news that Pakistan has bought eight
diesel-electric submarines from China, which could be equipped with nuclear
missiles.
Pakistan currently has
extensive land and air based nuclear capabilities.
With the development of Pakistan’s newest missile, Shaheen-III,
which has a range of 2,750 kilometers, Pakistan is capable of hitting all of
India and can also reach Israel.
Pakistani F-16 fighters can also drop nuclear bombs deep in Indian
territory and can hit major cities like Mumbai and Delhi. Finally, Pakistan is
believed to be developing tactical, battlefield nuclear weapons, which are
necessary for its strategy to counter India. Pakistan’s
Nasr Missile has a range of 60 kilometers.
Pakistan does not have to
worry about its second strike capabilities to the extent that some other
countries do because of its size, which allows nuclear weapons to be scattered
around multiple sites and because it has not adopted a no-first-use nuclear
doctrine, meaning Pakistan is perfectly willing to use a nuke first, before
retaliation. This
hurts India’s nuclear deterrent capabilities, since theoretically
Pakistan can hit every Indian nuclear site first (India has a no-first use
policy).
Pakistan’s Alleged Nuclear Umbrella
Various reports indicate that
Pakistan has joined the United States in offering to use its nuclear weapons to
shield allies against nuclear threats. In Pakistan’s case, these countries
include the six Arab members of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), especially
Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia is said to have funded Pakistan’s continued
expansion of its nuclear stockpile
in return for a guarantee that Pakistan would provide Saudi Arabia
with a weapon or a nuclear shield in the case of Iran getting a bomb.
Therefore,
Pakistan’s nuclear program is not only a cause of instability in South Asia; it
also makes the Middle East much more dangerous. There is no guarantee that
Saudi Arabia may not try to secretly acquire a nuclear weapon from Pakistan no
matter what Iran does. The Wall Street Journal reported that Saudi Arabia all but
expects Pakistan’s instant support in the nuclear field whenever needed.
Future
Nuclear rivalry in South Asia has reached an especially dangerous phase as
Pakistan can now reach all of India and deploy battlefield nukes. The New
York Times is right to
note that in nuclear terms, Pakistan is the “biggest concern.”
Pakistan’s factional government filled with rogue agencies is a much bigger
threat to nuclear nonproliferation than Iran ever will be as there is no
guarantee that someone will not provide nuclear material to terrorists or rogue
groups despite orders not to do so. At least Iran is tightly controlled and
methodical about what it does.
Pakistan’s arsenal of 120
nuclear weapons is
rapidly growing, and could
triple in a decade, giving it more nukes than France, Britain, and
China. Yet Pakistan remains a desperately poor country, plagued by instability
and extremism. These make it especially dangerous and more likely that its
nuclear weapons will at some point be misused. All of this makes it more likely
that Pakistan will continue to avoid becoming a normal country, driven by trade
and development, and more likely to compensate for these failures through
distracting its population with the mostly baseless India threat.
Ultimately, Pakistan’s
behavior is unlikely to change because it can continue to support militants
against India without fear of major retaliation. The expansion of its nuclear
program merely reinforces this and adds to instability in South Asia. The only
incentive to change its way would be ideological, and Pakistan continues to
head in an even more radical direction while the military remains obsessed with
the threat of India over all else. Pakistan’s nuclear program has given
security in South Asia a very bleak future.
Akhilesh Pillalamarri is
an assistant editor at the National Interest
No comments:
Post a Comment