KEVIN RUDD'S latest solution to the dilemma posed by the Sri Lankan asylum seekers aboard the Oceanic Viking looks like abject surrender. Should these boat people accept his offer - this remains in doubt - they will be better off than if they had their way almost a month ago and been ferried to Christmas Island. If they disembark to the Indonesian island of Bintang, their processing there will be accelerated.
Thirty of the 78 asylum seekers who have already been deemed genuine refugees by the relevant United Nations agency are promised resettlement, not necessarily but probably in Australia, within six weeks. Those whose claims to protection have yet to be processed are guaranteed resettlement within 12 weeks if they are successful. Meanwhile, they will receive English lessons, help to contact their families and other support.
The problem is not that the deal is inappropriate or inhumane - indeed, something like it could and should have been offered weeks ago - but that, after so long and muddled a delay, what might have been seen as a decent humanitarian gesture now smacks of a desperate attempt by the Government to save face. The impression is that the Prime Minister, to avoid the embarrassment of allowing the Oceanic Viking's human cargo to disembark on Christmas Island, has instead made concessions under duress from a ragged boatload of castaways.
The question is whether the Sri Lankans will now overplay their hand by making unreasonable demands - demands the Australian Government could not meet without the agreement of the Indonesian authorities, who oppose putting them in community accommodation. The asylum seekers' reluctance to be housed in a detention centre is understandable - some have had distressing previous experience - but they now have a promise that their time in the new, Australian-funded one in Tanjung Pinang would be finite and relatively brief. Besides, even if the asylum seekers believe Kevin Rudd's boast that his patience is infinite, they should know the Australian public's patience, like Indonesia's, is not. They risk running out of sympathy.
Still, there are positives. One is that the Indonesian Government has now agreed to an indefinite extension of the deadline before the Oceanic Viking must leave its waters. This reduces the temptation for the asylum seekers to play a delaying game in the hope that Jakarta will leave the ship with no option but Christmas Island.
Second, diplomatic talks between Australia and Sri Lanka, particularly about increased humanitarian migration, offer some prospect of alleviating the people-smuggling problem at source. The Sydney Morning Herald Editorial
Scientists question a government report saying the Himalayan ice cover isn't shrinking
The great glaciers of the Himalaya may not be melting as fast as thought, and in fact some may even be growing, according to a controversial report for India’s Ministry of Environment and Forests that has been greeted with disbelief by environmentalists.
The 60-page report released this week, "Himalayan Glaciers, A State-of-Art Review of Glacial Studies, Glacial Retreat and Climate Change," has set off a furor in India.
The condition of the glaciers is of paramount concern to South Asia, which depends on them as by far the region’s single biggest source of water. They fill the Ganges as well as the Brahmaputra in Bangladesh, the Mekong, which flows through Southeast Asia, the Irrawaddy in Burma, the Indus in Pakistan and the Yellow and Yangtze Rivers of China.
In its own report on India, "Global Climate Change: An Introduction," written by Sudip Mitra, the UN panel on climate change said that in the last 100 years the mean annual surface air temperature of the earth has increased by 0.4-0.6C and that it could rise another 3 to 5C by the end of the 21st century, with North India likely to become the warmest part of the country.
The Himalaya report, prepared by the GB Pant Institute of Himalayan Environment and Development, carried the cautionary statement that its conclusions "are not necessarily endorsed by the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India. This series is meant to serve as a basis for informed debate and discussion on critical issues related to the environment." Nonetheless, it assumes additional significance because of the United Nations Climate Change Conference to be held in Copenhagen from Dec. 7 through Dec. 18 and appears certain to be cited by those who claim climate change is a fraud. The Copenhagen conference is the most significant climate change panel since the Kyoto Conference of Parties in 1997, which produced the Kyoto Protocol in which 38 developed countries agreed to specific targets for cutting their emissions of greenhouse gases, although the United States, the world’s largest emitter of greenhouse gases, never ratified the treaty. It became international law in 2005.
India has so far strongly opposed any binding emission targets for developing countries and, in recent negotiations in Bangkok to come up with a framework for the Copenhagen conclave, led the opposition to an Australian proposal backed by the United States and the European Union to establish a single legal instrument to reduce emissions worldwide.
The Himalaya report quotes data going back 150 years on India’s glaciers, the most extensive in the world outside of the polar ice caps. Fears of glacial retreat almost a century ago led to efforts to monitor the glaciers, according to the report, with 20-odd glaciers from Jammu and Kashmir west to Sikkim under observation by the Geological Survey of India. The studies, according to the report, show that "All the glaciers under observation during the last three decades of 20th century have shown cumulative negative mass balance." Degeneration of the glacier mass has been the highest in Jammu & Kashmir, relatively lower in Himachal Pradesh, even lower in Uttarakhand and the lowest in Sikkim."
The region’s glaciers, "although shrinking in volume and constantly showing a retreating front, have not in any way exhibited, especially in recent years, an abnormal annual retreat, of the order that some glaciers in Alaska and Greenland are reported to have done."
However, the Web site Science Daily reported in 2007 that "satellite-imagery derived glacier surface topographies obtained at intervals of a few years were adjusted and compared. Calculations indicated that 915 square kilometers of Himalayan glaciers of the test region…thinned by an annual average of 0.85 m between 1999 and 2004." Satellite data from the Indian Space Applications Center in Ahmedabad, indicates that from 1962 to 2004, more than 1,000 Himalayan glaciers have retreated by around 16 percent. According to the Chinese Academy of Sciences, China's glaciers have shrunk by 5 percent since 1950s.
Nonetheless, the report says, the Siachen glacier advanced by about 700 meters between 1862 and 1909, retreated rapidly by about 400 meters between 1929 and 1958, and has shown "hardly any retreat during the last 50 years, the report said. The Gangotri glacier, which had been retreating rapidly along the front at about 20 meters per year until 2000, "has has since slowed down considerably, and between September 2007 and June 2009 is practically at a standstill. The same is true of the Bhagirathkharak and Zemu glaciers."
Thus, the report said, "It is premature to make a statement that glaciers in the Himalayas are retreating abnormally because of the global warming. A glacier is affected by a range of physical features and a complex interplay of climatic factors. It is therefore unlikely that the snout [the leading edge of a glacier] movement of any glacier can be claimed to be a result of periodic climate variation until many centuries of observations become available. While glacier movements are primarily due to climate and snowfall, snout movements appear to be peculiar to each particular glacier."
Asia Sentinel
What will happen in Copenhagen?
All who are supposed to be bright, scientific and concerned about the fate of mankind and the planet must contribute to solving the climate change/global warming problem. On Wednesday, in Singapore, at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) meeting of foreign and other ministers, in preparation for this weekend’s APEC summit meeting, the United States Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called on world leaders to be prepared to agree on a compromise at next month’s talks in Copenhagen.
“We cannot let the pursuit of perfection get in the way of progress,” Secretary Clinton said.
The December 7 to 18 Copenhagen talks are organized to achieve a global agreement on slashing greenhouse gas emissions to reduce the impact of climate change before the Kyoto Protocol expires in 2012. But the US is not a signatory of the Kyoto Treaty, which then President G. W. Bush did not wish to bind US business and industry.
President Barack Obama will attend the summit in Singapore.
One of Obama’s first acts was to bring the USA into the climate-change negotiations. That is one reason he is very popular abroad.
Secretary Clinton said if all the countries “exert maximum effort and embrace the right blend of pragmatism and principle, I believe we can secure a strong outcome at Copenhagen.”
She also said, “we [the US] are committed to reaching the goal of a global, legally binding climate agreement, and will continue working vigorously with the international community toward that end.”
She affirmed that she had “fruitful discussions” on climate change with counterparts from the 21-member APEC forum, whose members include China, Russia, Japan and other countries of the Pacific Rim.
The APEC member countries account for 60 percent of global greenhouse emissions that pollute the Earth and cause global warming and climate change. But the industrialized countries, especially the US and China (which are the top emitters), cause some 90 percent of the harmful emissions while the Philippines emits very much less than 1 percent and is considered to be adding virtually no harm to the planet. This has emboldened President Arroyo to call for a system in which the heaviest polluters and greenhouse gas emitters should pay the non-emitting countries. These are actually more vulnerable to climate change.
Despite Secretary Clinton’s plea for cooperation and compromise, most experts think, as of this writing, that the possibility of the Copenhagen meeting reaching a decisive agreement to correct and strengthen the Kyoto Protocol is zero.
Therefore, mankind and our planet are doomed—if some of the more scary prophets are to be believed.
There have been several preparatory meetings prior to the Copenhagen one next month. Representatives of 180 nations have joined in these talks throughout the world. None of the meetings gives hope there will be a happy compromise as Secretary Clinton called for in Singapore.
If God wills that a compromise arises out of the APEC Leaders’ Summit this weekend, then perhaps the APEC countries could persuade the rest of the world.
But the biggest opposing views are those of the Western industrialized countries, principally the US (the second biggest emitter) versus China and India. The latter two would not agree to be bound by new strict limits if the USA does not agree to much greater limits. They argue that the older industrialized countries were the ones that caused more damage through the past centuries. They should be penalizecd while China and India should not be prevented from achieving higher levels of industrialization using greenhouse gas emitting fuels. China is the No. 1 emitter country. India is No. 4.
There is supposed to be a United Nations Adaptation Fund, which kicked in 2008, to help less developed countries pay for projects to curb the effects of global warming. The rich industrialized countries were supposed to contribute to the fund. Until now the fund is only $18 million. Together, our Manny Pacquiao, Dr. Lucio Tan, Taipans Henry Sy and Lance Gokongwei and a couple of our jueteng lords would be able to comfortably donate more than that laughable amount.
What me worry?
The battle between the US et al. and China-India et al. appears to have assumed an ideological overtone. Yet both of the two opposed blocs don’t seem to mind the global-warming/climate change status quo.
Why?
Could the reason be that both sides have in fact decided to side with those scientists who dispute the
UN-backed finding of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) because it is pure bunkum?
The number of scientists who don’t buy the IPCC’s frightening scenario is growing. Numbers have made them sound less like voices from the fringe.
Those who are now making fun of Al Gore’s fame and profitable advocacy have doubled, at least in colleges and in the Internet.
We can imagine Beavis and Butthead, and oh yes, MAD’s Alfred E. Neuman, smiling at our global warming fears and telling us:
The ice caps have melted before. Yes, carbon emissions have increased in the last century because of fossil fuels. Yes, global average temperature has increased 0.8 degrees F. But, hey, the temperature increase came first—before 1940, 20 years before the surge of carbon emissions from the geometrically increased population of cars, trucks and factories! How can we trust scientists who call the results the cause?
The anti-IPCC scientists have many more words to say.
But one remembers that only 30 years ago, the scare was against the New Ice Age. So scientists were introducing ideas to cover the ice caps with soot and black paint to make them absorb more heat and get melted faster. (Excerpt from Manila Times)

MANILA - A war of words between the Philippine government and a separatist Muslim rebel group over the kidnapping of an Irish missionary threatens to derail the lobbying efforts of the United States to bring the two sides back to peace negotiations.
The renewed animosity has flared up ahead of US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's scheduled arrival in Manila on Thursday for a two-day visit to press Manila and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) to resume their stalled peace talks. Clinton, who will later proceed to Singapore for an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) meeting, is expected to reiterate Washington's long-standing offer to help push the talks to restore peace and normalcy in the southern Philippine island of Mindanao.
Malaysia had previously brokered the talks, but it seems no longer keen to host further meetings after it last year pulled out its contingent of "peace monitors" from Mindanao. Backed by the Organization of Islamic Conference, Malaysia expressed frustration over the continued hostilities between security forces and the MILF which led to the collapse of the ceasefire agreement.
The possibility of resuming negotiations also appears dim after Manila accused the MILF of involvement in the October 11 abduction of an Irish priest, Michael Sinnot. The 79-year-old Sinnot was seized by armed men in Pagadian city, 1,000 kilometers south of Manila, and reportedly brought to MILF-controlled areas in the predominantly Muslim province of Lanao del Sur.
Interior and Local Government Secretary Ronaldo Puno said the MILF was responsible for the Catholic priest's abduction and that the government would not entertain the kidnappers' demand for a US$12 million ransom in exchange for the prelate's freedom.
But the MILF, which boasts 12,000 fighters, strongly denied the government's charge, branding it as "cheap propaganda" and "an affront to the peace process".
As tensions mounted anew in Mindanao, hundreds of residents in some Maguindanao towns reportedly fled after the MILF began massing its heavily armed forces following rumors that the military was poised to launch rescue operations. Despite the row over Sinnot's kidnapping, senior US Embassy officials in Manila have held clandestine meetings with MILF leaders in their Maguindanao camp. The US Embassy has kept mum on the meetings, but on its website, the MILF confirmed in a statement that it had held talks with a visiting group of American diplomats led by the US Embassy charge d'affaires, Leslie Basset, on October 16.
The US is a major aid donor, including for various development projects, making it a key stakeholder in Mindanao's peace process. It has provided funds and built roads, bridges, school buildings and other infrastructure projects, particularly in impoverished Muslim-populated areas in Mindanao.
As part of the Visiting Forces Agreement, the US has also extended training and intelligence support to Filipino troops in their counter-terrorism operations. MILF vice chairman Ghazali Jaafar told the visiting US diplomats that the MILF welcomed Washington's offer to push the peace process.
On President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo's request, Malaysia has been facilitating the talks since 2001 to help put an end to the Muslim insurgency in Mindanao that has claimed 120,000 lives and displaced more than two million people. The current US ambassador, Kristie Kenney, who also previously visited MILF leaders in their camp for talks, said the US was leaving it to Manila and the MILF to decide what role the US would play in the talks.
Despite the MILF's well-documented acts of terrorism violence, the US has surprisingly excluded the secessionist group from its global list of terrorist organizations. The Islamic extremists Abu Sayyaf and communist-led New People's Army are currently the only Philippine groups on Washington's list.
By Al Labita who has worked as a journalist for over 30 years, including as a regional bureau chief and foreign editor for the Philippine News Agency. He has worked as a Manila correspondent for several major local publications and wire agencies in Australia, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore and the United Kingdom.

THE Australian government came to Sri Lanka this week bearing gifts in the hope of winning co-operation in its bid to reduce asylum-seeker numbers.
One was material: $11 million towards de-mining the former northern conflict zone and resettling about 250,000 civilians still held behind razor wire in internally displaced people (IDP) camps. The other was less tangible: rhetoric that pandered to the Sri Lankan view that most asylum-seekers are Tamil Tigers seeking to reinvigorate the separatist struggle from distant shores.
Both bore the whiff of appeasement.
While the EU is poised to withdraw Sri Lanka's tax exemption status for textile exports, worth $US3.3 billion annually, because of reported human rights abuses there, and the US administration has called for the camps and former conflict zones to be opened to international scrutiny, Australian officials say they prefer a more "constructive" approach.
In a joint news conference late on Monday night to announce a memorandum of understanding on people-smuggling, Foreign Minister Stephen Smith emphasised the importance of apprehending and prosecuting criminal and terror syndicates behind the
Australia's latest financial contribution will provide $6m to clear mines in resettlement areas, $2m for food assistance to people who have been resettled and $3m through the UN for housing reconstruction work. Excerpt from The Australian article by Amanda Hodge
HUA HIN, Thailand - Cambodia's long-serving Prime Minister Hun Sen, with a thumping parliamentary majority and a war-traumatized electorate fearful of change, may well have one of the safest jobs in world politics. This certainly seems the case in comparison with neighboring Thailand, where the premiership has changed hands four times in the past two years.
Nonetheless, Hun Sen is likely grateful for the popularity boost Thailand's government may have handed him through its heated response to his recent praise of and job offer to former Thai premier Thaksin Shinawatra. Hun Sen appointed Thaksin, who has been criminally convicted on corruption charges, as an economic advisor. The latter, who was toppled in a 2006 military coup, now lives in exile. Last month, Hun Sen hailed Thaksin as a "great friend" and a victim of a politically compromised judicial system.
The Thai government has viewed the offer as interference in its internal affairs and downgraded diplomatic relations. Angry protests have erupted at the Cambodian Embassy in Bangkok, and both nations last week recalled their respective ambassadors. Armed troops have also lined up to defend the Thai Embassy in Cambodia's capital, Phnom Penh, but few Cambodians expect a repeat of the 2003 anti-Thai riots, which saw the embassy burned to the ground and Thailand ready airplanes to evacuate its nationals in a dispute sparked by a Thai actress' alleged comments over national ownership of Cambodia's famed Angkor Wat temple.
Some Cambodians, accustomed to Hun Sen's well-known tactic of bolstering his political clout by offering loyalists plum advisor posts, see the latest spat in less emotive terms. In the leadup to 2008 elections, Hun Sen's ruling Cambodian People's Party (CPP) attracted many high-level defectors from the main opposition, the Sam Rainsy Party (SRP), to join his army of over 100 well-paid advisors.
Hun Sen has said he would refuse to honor a bilateral extradition treaty with Thailand that would require him to arrest and deport Thaksin, who faces a two-year jail sentence in Thailand on the corruption conviction. Although Thaksin remains a divisive figure with great sway in Thai politics, Bangkok's reaction may be over more than political insecurities.
Billionaire Thaksin was appointed by royal decree last Wednesday as an advisor to both Hun Sen and Cambodian King Norodom Sihamoni. He is scheduled to land in Phnom Penh on November 12 to deliver a lecture to Cambodian economic officials and there are rumors circulating that he might meet with a group of Thai "red-shirt" protest leaders near the Thai border.
In Cambodia, the monarchy is seen as fair game for criticism by both the media and public. After observing for years former king Sihanouk's extravagant lifestyle and constant shifts to ensure his political survival - as well as political forays by other royal princes and princesses - many Cambodians are skeptical of the monarchy. The situation is very different in Thailand, where the monarchy is widely revered and where any perceived criticism of the crown can result in harsh jail sentences. One motivation cited by military coup-makers for their 2006 putsch was that Thaksin was disloyal to the crown - charges he's denied.
The differences between the two nations' histories and economic situations seem personified by their leaders. Thailand, one of the region's wealthiest nations and a member of the influential Group of 20, is led by Oxford-educated Abhisit Vejjajiva.
Cambodia, still impoverished after a three-decade civil war and traumatized by the killings of the genocidal Khmer Rouge, is led by Hun Sen, a once barefoot temple boy who lived on handouts from Buddhist monks before becoming a teenage soldier. He first fought for the Khmer Rouge - a struggle that cost him his left eye - and then as part of the Vietnamese offensive that liberated the nation from the same radical Maoist regime in 1979.
Abhisit may have had a comparatively privileged upbringing, but Hun Sen enjoys political advantages. A seasoned leader, Hun Sen is in his 25th year in office - making his one of the longest-running premierships in the world. He led the CPP to 58% of the vote at general elections held in 2008, eclipsing widely the opposition SRP.
Abhisit, on the other hand, took charge last year as a result of Thailand's Constitutional Court disbanding the Thaksin-aligned ruling People's Power Party (PPP), which defeated his Democrat party at 2007 polls, on electoral fraud charges. His predecessor, Somchai Wongsawat, Thaksin's brother-in-law, was in the job for only 75 days. Somchai's PPP predecessor, Samak Sundaravej, lasted only nine months after he was ousted by a Thai court on corruption charges.
It is not the first time that Hun Sen has capitalized on political turmoil in Thailand, especially since bilateral tensions were re-ignited last year over the contested ownership of the land surrounding the ancient Preah Vihear temple, perched atop a steep cliff on the Thai-Cambodian border. When a United Nations body sided with Cambodia's claim, Thai nationalists ran across the border, prompting a military build-up by both sides.
Phnom Penh first appealed to the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and then to the UN Security Council to take note of the issue, taking the diplomatic high road. It is unclear how the Preah Vihear dispute would have played out if Thaksin, also Hun Sen's golfing buddy, had still been in charge in Thailand. Some critics say the current tension is in part due to false assurances given in the past by Thaksin to Hun Sen about border delineation near the temple and other overlapping claims by the two countries. Thaksin's critics claim that he was willing to offer territorial concessions to Hun Sen in exchange for personal business interests, claims the exiled former premier has denied.
Thaksin last year proposed a multi-million dollar deal with Hun Sen to develop Cambodia's southwestern maritime province of Koh Kong, telling Thai media that he wanted to turn it into a "second Hong Kong". Hun Sen hailed the proposal as an
opportunity to reduce poverty in Cambodian-Thai border areas. Hun Sen's main domestic opponent says the premier's overtures to Thaksin are not motivated by scoring political points or a desire to uphold Khmer nationalism, but instead are due to pressure being exerted on him by Vietnam, the invading nation which initially installed him as premier in 1985 and which the opposition still claims has influence over the CCP government.
By Craig Guthrie Asia Times Online correspondent Thailand

Om Swastiastu ...
There's two articles on the continuing rabies epidemic in Bali. While the disease spreads, animal rights groups are warning the government that current measures are cruel, ineffective and likely to create a swelling rat infestation of Bali.We learned of the death last Sunday of long-time Bali resident, Bob Monkhouse - an award-winning champion of those trying to kick drug and alcohol habits in Bali and a guardian angel to our Bali neighbors afflicted with HIV/AIDS.We've got the results on the Commonwealth Bank Tennis Tournament just concluded in Bali which had an anti-climactic ending and the surprise suspension of one of the top players for failing to obey drug use protocols.
Last week a reformed Malaysian jihadist came to Bali and shared his insights on the workings of the terrorist mind and why Bali may remain a target for future terror attacks.
Earthquakes, landslides, floods and fires were all parts of an important emergency preparedness drill recently conducted in North Bali. We've got the details.
Governor Pastika sings praises on the way Malaysia promotes its tourism, wondering if there aren't lessons to be learned from our neighbors to the north. Meanwhile, business is booming from Kuala Lumpur to Bali as Malaysian Airlines now flies 3 times each day to Bali.
Looking for something to do in Bali? There's details of a one-month photographic exhibition near Nusa Dua; a contemporary painting exhibition by 4 Indonesian artists in Ubud; an open golf tournament at the Bali Nirwana Golf Course on November 14th; and a kids' day the the Bali Nikko Resort on November 15th.
There's also an interview with Indonesian spiritual guru Anand Krishna on the First Annual Bali Meditators Conference to be held in Ubud November 14-16, 2009.
Looking for rooms over the coming Christmas season? Contact us at info@balidiscovery.com for the best deals going.
To get Bali news as it happens, follow me on Twitter.com at http://twitter.com/BaliUpdateEd
Om Çanti Çanti Çanti Om ...
J.M. Daniels - Bali Update
Bali Discovery Tours
For the full report go to: http://www.balidiscovery.com/update/update687.asp